Despite the title, I promise not to make this too depressing. However, I’m back in a hard running mode and this is where my mind has been during every run for a couple weeks. I promise there will be something useful.
I’ve been thinking about all the funerals I’ve ever been to and realized that the majority have been for dead friends that barely made it past 30 either because of disease, suicide, or war. I want to tell you about two:
Duane
Duane was a soft-spoken man who really took care of me when I came to work for him. He was my boss and friend who suffered from depression for most of his life that he hid quite effectively and was outwardly a very positive and upbeat person. He had a young family. He was an amazing drummer. He was a cool boss who liked to make things fun, and would tell us “this doesn’t have to suck.” He was right, and I had a blast at that job and had no idea he struggled with depression.
One day Duane felt himself spiraling so went to a local hospital and asked to be admitted and treated for depression. He had been medicated in the past and that kept him straight, but in this case, the hospital did not treat him and told him to come back if the condition persisted. He went home and committed suicide that evening.
That was the first funeral I had ever been to, and I remember the priest telling us that Duane had sinned — meaning, I assume, that he was now in Hell.
Steve
Steve was a giant, loyal man who was always pissed off. He was incredibly intelligent and had one of the sharpest and most fearlessly sarcastic senses of humor that I have ever encountered because he was miserable. He reported in to my unit on September 11th, 2001 in the middle of DEFCON Delta and we were deployed 1 month early as a result — with no scheduled return date. We became instant friends as we worked extraordinarily long hours in the same confined space and forged a deep understanding of each other that happens when people suffer together — lots of laughing, bitching, dreaming, and philosophizing. We worked some intense ops together, and for some reason he always put on the song, “Africa” by Toto looping in the background for hours. I didn’t mind.
Steve got really, really sick out of nowhere. A lot of people thought he was malingering because everybody knew how miserable he was and wanted out. I could see in his eyes it was real, though. He could barely walk, so was medevac’ed. With a helicopter hovering overhead I rigged the rescue stretcher that would take him to a hospital, and he stared at me in pain. I went to signal the helo, but he grabbed my hand in his enormous hand, and I knew he was scared which scared me — I had never seen him like that. I got close and shouted above the noise that I would see him soon. Stretcher up. Tagline removed. Helo on the horizon. No more “Africa.”
Steve spent the next 2 years in undiagnosed pain and fell into a deep depression. He moved to his parents’ home which embarrassed him and often could barely move. I was deployed all the time, so only kept up with email. He went through a lot and his writing became deeply introspective and profound. He talked about the time he served in the Middle East, and he felt a lot of remorse for complaining so much while he was healthy.
He did have periods of improvement and would try to go hunting with his brothers on his good days. I gave him my Remington 870 Express shotgun because I had given up shooting at birds, and he got a dog as a companion. One evening he was in a hotel with his brother preparing for a hunting trip and started feeling poorly so he sought the nearest Veteran’s Administration hospital and requested to be admitted. The VA rejected him and sent him home — again untreated and undiagnosed. He died that night.
I was so angry with the VA for months that it started to burn me up a bit, and I ultimately had to let it go because I could find no positive resolution. I realized that the VA is merely a giant bureaucracy that struggles when presented with situations outside the manual and that Steve went untreated mostly out of a systemic failure and a lack of energetic innovation. I’ve worked in tough bureaucracies and what takes a normal person 15 minutes in the outside takes 3 months on the inside unless somebody is willing to break a whole pile of rules. Nobody was willing to take the 3 months or break the rules, I guess. This is a system where “fault” is impossible and Steve’s death, while perhaps preventable, is simply a passage. Declaring war on bureaucracy is like declaring war on terror. It is an ideology with no clear enemy — only agents and believers. I can find no utility in assigning blame.
My father is a great man, and one of the simplest and most helpful things he ever said to me was, “when somebody asks for help, you help them.” I remember very clearly when he told me this as a result of Duane’s death. He was very broken up about the situation, and it’s become a guiding principle for me.
But help is a funny thing to figure out. Constantly giving somebody what they tell you they need versus finding out what they REALLY need is a serious challenge. A homeless person on the street needs help that is both immediate and apparent, but the condition that caused homelessness is most likely not going to be unraveled right there on the street.
An artist sometimes needs help to find inspiration. An empty person needs help finding meaning. A garden needs help to thrive and produce.
The core of help is a connection that becomes severed by a factory mentality. Patients are processed, resources are extracted, products are manufactured, waste is removed. Do you feel a connection to any of the 10,000 widgets made today? Can you feel affection for a cost-minimizing, lowest skill level possible process? I was surprised to find in a military manual just how much money a soldier gets for losing a leg. There’s a number because an actuary figured out how much a leg, eyesight, or mental instability cost. While this creates a very efficient system, it fails at everything “undetermined.”
The faceless nature of corporatized “help” doesn’t always yield the intended result. Institutionalized help feels more like maintenance. Once life becomes a process that can be written in a manual, we separate from meaning and cognition. If you’re working with TGIF laborers in a law firm, hospital, restaurant, military unit, or hardware store you’re running the risk of being swept up in a process that consumes its own citizenry then claims, “there’s nothing we could have done.”
There’s nothing that could be done because nobody did anything and it became institutional. Does this mean I believe those hospitals wanted my friends to die? Absolutely NOT. I believe most of those people had every intention of doing the right thing, so how does the wrong thing happen? How is it that some things suffer while others mend?
So, listen to this cheesy song from 1982 and think about it. I’ve probably heard it 1000 times. In this case, there is nothing to be angry about, just remembered.
“I seek to cure what’s deep inside, frightened of this thing that I’ve become.”
{ 13 comments… read them below or add one }
All we can do is “be there” when our friends need us, and carry with us the best of them when they are gone.
I too have a friend I’ve known for 40 years who has clinical depression and posttramatic stress from his tour of duty. It tears me up that all I can do is go and make him laugh till he chokes over “old times”, knowing that ten minutes after I leave he might decide he’s had all he can stand…. So I listen to another cheesy song.
http://www.youtube.com/watch#!v=HDl3iUo__dY&feature=related
I love that song. The beat makes me want to do that Watusi shuffle-thing. Must be my genes.
I’ve lost jobs because I’ve gone outside the book trying to help someone. It drives me crazy to be prevented from doing my JOB because I had to follow some rules. Most people won’t even try if it means their job. That shit only ends well in the movies.
“I remember the priest telling us that Duane had sinned — meaning, I assume, that he was now in Hell.”
That really burns me up (no pun intended). It reminds me of my aunt’s service where the smarmy preacher boy went on a long long litany of now she’s in Heaven and of all the things she wouldn’t see in heaven, including every vice and bad thing you can imagine (stuff I didn’t even know existed, the SOB). My reaction, was WTF you bastard you just ruined her service. Everyone else seemed to think nothing of it.
To use the insurance industry phrase:
It’s only “suicide while sane” that is not covered.
Why God wouldn’t have a similar policy, I don’t know….
Your cheesy song is stuck in my head now, Tommy. I used to listen to that album a lot.
Whenever I think of all the people who are overwhelmed or discarded by the System, I think of this song:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RcX1qA1Etc8&feature=related
“Won’t you please tell me what we’ve learned?
I know it sounds absurd,
But please tell me who I am..”
Haha! Yeah that song is super catchy. It won’t go away anytime soon.
One of the reasons the wrong thing happens is because people are punished for doing what is right.
“Africa,” by the way, is a great song.
“I was about 11 when the New York’s World Fair took place, and I went to the African pavilion with my family. I saw the real thing; I don’t know what tribe, but there were these drummers playing, and my mind was blown. The thing that blew my mind was everybody was playing one part. As a little kid in Connecticut, I would see these Puerto Rican and Cuban cats jamming in the park. It was the first time I witnessed someone playing one beat and not straying from it, like a religious experience, where it gets loud, and everyone goes into a trance. I have always dug those kind of orchestras, whether it be a band or all drummers. But I just love a band of guys saying one thing. That’s why I loved marching band, and I said, ‘Gee, someday there’s going to be a little drum orchestra where everybody plays one thing, and you don’t stray from it. You do it until you drop. You’re banished from that land if you move from that one part.
So when we were doing ‘Africa’, I set up a bass drum, snare drum and a hi-hat, and Lenny Castro set up right in front of me with a conga. We looked at each other and just started playing the basic groove….”
- Jeff Porcaro
Yeah, I’ve already told my friends (correction, friend since I only have one) that I want him to go to my fav restaurant for my memorial service and eat my fav food (chilis) and talk about my fav topic (fossil hunting) with whoever else wants to go.
No preachers allowed. And now I want Africa played too.
“When somebody asks for help, you help them.”
Good advice. The smallest things make the biggest difference in the lives of others.
I’d add – when you see somebody who needs your help, you help them.
I don’t go around looking to be helpful…some of us have heightened awareness and are intuitively tuned into the feelings/needs of others. As a result, you see what is needed and what needs to be done. You intervene only when asked or when someone is clearly in need. Having discernment is the key. My husband of 5 years has finally made peace with my helpful nature (which was making him crazy) by declaring once and for all: “You LOVE everybody, and I just have to accept that!”.
“But help is a funny thing to figure out. “
You do your best to understand what is needed and work within the scope of your ability. I am certain that most of us manage to figure out enough to be truly helpful. It is the HEART guides the process of helping, therefore the result is assured.
Chinle,
Awesome. Fossil hunting and Toto… how could that get any better?
Will,
You’re right. It is great. I love this song.
“…merely a giant bureaucracy that struggles when presented with situations outside the manual and that Steve went untreated mostly out of a systemic failure and a lack of energetic innovation. I’ve worked in tough bureaucracies and what takes a normal person 15 minutes in the outside takes 3 months on the inside unless somebody is willing to break a whole pile of rules.”
It’s actually much worse than this, no where as passive as described. As we watch the collapse of the welfare-central-banking-warfare model, the public sector of the pie must keep expanding its arc-length in order to remain as big of a piece. This must be gobbled from the private sector. Behold the great “Atlas Shrugged,” quotation:
“Did you really think we want those laws observed?” said Dr. Ferris. “We want them to be broken. You’d better get it straight that it’s not a bunch of boy scouts you’re up against… We’re after power and we mean it… There’s no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren’t enough criminals one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws. Who wants a nation of law-abiding citizens? What’s there in that for anyone? But just pass the kind of laws that can neither be observed nor enforced or objectively interpreted – and you create a nation of law-breakers – and then you cash in on guilt. Now that’s the system, Mr. Reardon, that’s the game, and once you understand it, you’ll be much easier to deal with.”
Mike
Two questions: What was Steve’s illness, did you ever find out? Why not go to a regular hospital?
VA hospitals often fail to do what they were intended for. I have always felt both the government and the GI’s would be better off eliminating the VA hospitals and just use the civilian health care system with the government picking up the tab if they would have under the VA system.
Gone,
They never diagnosed Steve’s illness. He went to a VA hospital because that is what he is supposed to do depending on the circumstance. Also, the VA had all of his prior records, and since his case was complex and ongoing he chose that option while he was out of town. Of course, military guys can walk into any emergency room in the country and it should be covered (key word: “should”), but he knew he would be treated with some pain killer and sent home.
The VA swings wildly which is strange. Within the VA I’ve received the best health care and worst health care experiences of my life. It’s hit or miss depending on who shows up for work that day. I think civilian health care is similar.